Posted in Of Musicals

Book Review: 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die

1001-albums-you-must-hear-before-you-die
A Lad Insane: 2016 Edition

You can daydream with music … it takes you away and creates a new world. – Tim Buckley

I’ve always wondered about the word well-read, and by extension what could be called well-watched, or well-listened. How do we exactly cover all bases with these distinct areas of knowledge? Who decides what constitutes being well-listened? Am I well-listened if I can remember note for note all of Beethoven’s symphonies? Or am I well-listened if I say, “Megadeth makes my ears bleed. And I can confirm this because I’ve listened to ALL their albums, and they’ve consistently made me reach for fresh bandages.”

Say, you have a plumbing problem. You pick up a How-To on plumbing. You find it fascinating, and then move on to The History of Plumbing. Things get too intense, and your kitchen pipes are not working yet. That’s when you find a 1001 Ways to Solve All Your Plumbing Issues. More than a thousand may seem intimidating at first, but it makes thing more interesting and doable than a lengthy history book.

Not that I didn’t find 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die [Edited by Robert Dimery] intimidating. I only picked it up because I have been following Geoff Stephen’s excellent blog 1001 Albums in 10 Years. He has been hosting a weekly quiz on the ‘Artist of the Week’, and that taps right into my geeky love for music and quizzing. You could say at nearly 1000 pages, this was both preparation for that, and a general ‘How do I become Well-Listened.’ I read it cover to cover (anyone else reads reference books cover to cover? Just me?), which is not the best way to go about a book like this. This is more of a life resolution thing, and ideally you should pick it up at your own leisure, read a bit till you find something interesting, and then make good of your music streaming subscription and listen to that album. If you are interested in doing something like that, this book is for you.

There is a lot of pop music criticism jargon, which can get annoying if you read things at a go. There’s an awful lot about The Byrds in the first 200 pages or so. Really. If they’re not reviewing The Byrds, they are referring to The Byrds, which given that this period of time also had The Beatles as active, contemporary players, makes me question the making of the universe.

1011002
RockBird: Deborah Harry

They’ve made considerable effort in providing you with an idea for each album within a short space. They contextualize it both in its social and cultural history, as well as the history of the genre. I also appreciate their efforts to list those responsible for art direction on each album. I would have found things easier if they had mentioned genre, but this layout suits me fine.

All the albums would qualify as popular music from the 1950s till present day, popular in North America and the UK, whether they be indigenous or ‘world’. You get to read about them chronologically, where every section is divided by decade, except for the noughties and the 2010’s, which makes a slim 100 pages when compared to the 200 of the nineties. The book is quite regularly updated. Mine was a library copy of the 2014 edition with Joy Division’s Unknown Pleasures on the cover, while the latest is from 2016 that has David Bowie’s Aladdin Sane on the cover. This is noteworthy, because the selection of 1001 albums vary considerably on each updated edition.

0711315cbae738a2b78012241f6ec6bc
Unknown Pleasures: Joy Division

Which defeats the whole purpose of calling it “Before You Die”. I would never pick up a book that tells me about the business of my own death. Like Who Will Cry When You Die ? (How will I know? I won’t be there.) or You’re Dead (Actually, I would read a book called that). But despite these updated versions of dying, what I most got out of the book was finding an album here and there that might not be by a big-name artist, may not have influenced many or sold millions, but has been deemed valuable/listenable by these critics, and I, in turn, have found them interesting too. I believe that’s one of the most valuable aspects of anthologies like this (yes, yes, I’ll get on with The Byrds), more than simply repeating all the awesome bigness of the Awesomely Big.

My only, MAJOR gripe is the extremely disparaging review of the one Bollywood album they condescended to include. There’s some Indian classical here and there (ticking all the big, contemporary names), but it’s as if the critic picked one random Bollywood album from a bargain bin or the pavements of Kolkata while he was on holiday because he recognised the name of composer R. D. Burman, and then chose to include it as his Indian popular music entry, because it’s the only thing he ever heard. I am personally offended, and I ask anybody wanting to listen to Indian popular music from the 1950s onwards (which includes much, much more than Bollywood) to not listen to this, or pay any heed to what that guy said. I’ll provide you with a list of choice, essential listening. Write me at ofopinions@gmail.com or comment below.

To end on a more positive note, here’s a quote by John Lennon mentioned in the book:

Well, you make your own dream. That’s The Beatles’ story, isn’t it?

What kind of music do you like to listen to?

Author:

Writer, Blogger, Kate Bush Fanatic

10 thoughts on “Book Review: 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die

  1. I have thumbed through an edition of this book before at the book store, but never broken down to purchase it. Part of it is that on any list like this I always find myself saying how dare they not include so and so. Or how could you choose THAT album over this one! Or feel slighted by the attitude behind the review. Sometimes I swear you can hear the sigh in the reviewers voice- ‘Well I guess I have to review something by The Byrds (to use one you mention) I suppose.’ It is probably something in my nature that makes me be that way and ever more curmudgeonly in my old age! You of course know a lot of the music I listen to so I’ll spare you a listing of my favorites! I do appreciate the diversity and inclusion of lesser known classics however. Awhile back someone gifted me an edition of the All Music Guide. It is very useful to have at home, especially in writing my blog, but of course I put it to the test early on for scoffing purposes. Aha…you mention Oysterband, but no Runrig! You have an entry for Blind Lemon Fuller but no Arthur Blake! I think I would be a nightmare to the people involved in these books! Lol.

    1. Ha ha! I did think of you while reading the Johnny Cash entries, and they were very respectful with him. There’s the usual sexism with many of the female artists. Because there were a number of writers, the styles were different. Some were written well, but what I found interesting is how one contradicted another unintentionally!
      I don’t think you need a book like this. You live in North America, you’ve probably grown up with this music (not that solitary Bollywood album I’m sure!), and you must be aware of certain people, even if you haven’t listened to them. I can estimate having listened to 1/5th of the albums, but I would like to listen to more, especially the list I compiled of albums that are new/interesting to me. I’m also more interested to listen to soul properly (something I keep meaning to) and give heavy metal a proper shot (something I swore I would never do!).
      There’s some wrong info here and there too. Like Kanye interrupted Swift at the VMAs, not Grammys! He tried to storm on Beck at the Grammys, who was willing to fight back, but he chickened out before he even got up!

      1. I know what you mean. I have had for years now a Rolling Stone history of rock book. Three writers (forget which ones now) but they each did an era-origins to the 1950’s, 60’s -70’s, and then 70’s to current (at the time). The last was the weakest because not enough time had passed. But having three writers was also ultimately confusing and problematic. And looking back now, it was sexist by and large. I do like seeing lists though just to see what’s on it! I have gotten heavily into soul the last few years quite happily 😄

      2. I find it very hard to find an appropriate Kate Bush review. I can write a whole book tearing down all her reviews from establishments like Rolling Stone!
        I find it better to watch documentaries because the artists get to speak for themselves and there aren’t too many “talking heads”.

  2. Thanks for the tip of the hat Amrita!
    I’m impressed you read it cover-to-cover – I had forgotten it had so much about the Byrds, perhaps that’s why I haven’t embraced any of their albums as much as I feel I should have, or as much as the books seems to imply that I should!
    Nice review!

    1. I actually quite enjoyed The Byrds when I listened to them years ago. But, the book seems to imply they invented pop music! Or set definitive standards. Even then, I was more surprised to see there were more albums in the 90s section than 60s, considering many believe the latter to be the decade when music was at its peak. Top 5 idea: top 5 decades of music?
      I don’t think I’m going to fare better on your quiz even if I’ve read it now. Watching Wayne’s World would have been better prep!

  3. Like you, I find it odd that the original good idea has become a periodic franchise. I’m tempted to get an updated copy and write down all the excluded albums I now “Don’t have to listen to before I die”. Could save some time.

    1. Ha ha! I think you could get all the lists from all the editions on listchallenges.com and compare and see which ones are no longer morbidly mandatory listens. I can only compare the 2014 edition I’ve read with Geoff’s blog that’s based on the 2005 edition, and I think they’ve gotten better with their selection with time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s